Let’s Get a Few Things Straight

Common Core ArtThe Common Core State Learning Standards are standards. Not curriculum. Not tests. Not evaluation. Standards.

Standards are the “to do” list for learning. They are a list of the things we want students to know, understand, be able to do, and be like. In 1996, New York State issued a complete set of standards for all subject areas and grade levels. There were twenty-three sets of standards that were organized into seven bundles. For example, math, science, and technology were grouped together in a bundle of seven standards (and the accompanying detail). Similarly, Health, Physical Education and Family and Consumer Science were bundled together. The standards that were published in 1996 introduced the term Languages Other Than English (LOTE) to our vocabulary. The Career Development and Occupational Studies (CDOS) standards identified career-specific skills as well as the set of universal skills for all students (very similar to what we now call 21st century skills). All in all, this collection of standards specified the goals for the students of New York. Subsequently, content guides and other explanatory materials were released by SED, but the standards remained the same until the Common Core came along.

The development of the Common Core State Standards (repackaged as the Common Core Learning Standards in New York) was led by the governors and chief school officers from the states and not by the federal government. Most states quickly adopted the standards when they were released. New York added a little bit to the standards before adopting them, primarily early childhood level standards which weren’t originally included. The US Department of Education eventually incentivized the adoption of the Common Core with Race To The Top money, but they have never been a requirement. There is no law that says that states must use the Common Core.

It is important to have common standards in our states, if not nationally, because our society is so mobile. It’s much better for our children if they pick up where they left off when they move or relocate. It’s also more efficient to develop educational resources when there is a commonality about what is to be learned, and when. Standards are no big deal – they are an agreed-upon “to do list.” Surely, it is a good idea to have common goals for our children and their education. New York is currently working on new sets of standards for science. Surely we should have science standards that are more recent than 1996. The Board of Regents should see a draft of science standards soon.

Different states have different standardized testing regimens but all are required, by No Child Left Behind (NCLB) to test all students each year in grades 3-8 English and mathematics, as well as once in high school math and English. A science testing requirement is also specified. Additionally, some states have more assessments that might be required. In New York, Regents Examinations have been a common part of high school life for more than a century. Although testing is a federal requirement, states are responsible for the development, administration, and results of assessments. Since NCLB started, different states have had different tests and different scoring requirements and implications. New York made a deliberate decision to change the 3-8 tests in order to align them to the Common Core Learning Standards. The State Education Department sets the cut-points. It was recently concluded that New York now has the most rigorous cut-points of any state in the country.

Whether or not you like the state tests, they are not a part of the Common Core Learning Standards. The standards are a list; they are not a test.

Teacher and principal evaluation is now tied to the results of these tests. This has been true since the Annual Professional Performance Review (APPR) scheme was changed to 3012-c. It is important to note that this is not when APPR began. As a condition for receiving Race To The Top funding, the state had to adopt such a system. Annual performance appraisals were required for teachers previous to this but were not tied to student achievement scores on state tests.

The Common Core Learning Standards are a list. They are not an evaluation system. They are not a series of tests. What happened was that the tests and evaluation system changed at approximately the same time as the Common Core Learning Standards were adopted. People have and continue to conflate these separate components of the system.

The drama in social media and in state and local politics continues to mix things up. Whether it is out of ignorance or because it plays well on the airwaves and in cyberspace is not clear. Nonetheless, the drama and conflation continues, and it just might be hurting our children. All of the drama detracts from the work that teachers and leaders are trying to do in our schools across the state. Teachers, administrators, and most importantly, students, have a finite amount of energy to give to the process of learning. The drama simply draws some of that finite energy away.

The standards are a list of things for our students to learn. Stop mixing up those lists with testing and evaluation schemes. If those need fixing, let’s fix them, but let’s talk about them as tests and evaluation schemes and not the Common Core. We have work in our schools that needs to be done.

Craig,-Jeff_WEBJeff Craig
Assistant Superintendent for Instructional Support Services

One thought on “Let’s Get a Few Things Straight

  1. The Standards are assessed via high stakes tests which are DIRECTLY tied to APPR measurements for teachers. The two issues are not conflated, they are intimately linked–50% intimately linked, to be exact. Therefore, while the Standards are appropriate measures of student learning, they most certainly an evaluation system for teachers. If you don’t believe me, ask and 4-8 teacher.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s